Trade period summary

[Jezza]

IN:
- Dayne Beams
- Jordan Roughead
- Pick 41
- Pick 44
- Pick 59
- Pick 60

OUT:
- Alex Fasolo (free agency)
- Pick 18
- Future 1st round pick
- Pick 51
- Pick 56
- Pick 75

How do you rate the trade period?

[K]

So, translated strictly to points (make up something for what the future pick will be), what was the net loss for Beams?

[stui magpie]

In isolation, it's not bad.

But, add to that we just picked up 2 cat b Irish KPP and kept enough points to get IQ and Kelly, I'd give it a big tick.

Like I said in another thread, it's a nice mix.

Trade for now bringing in a top if ageing mid and a premiership tall as KPP depth who can also ruck. Both positives.

Draft for the future. we bring in 2 cat B KPP and IQ and Kelly.

So we load up for now while we're right in the window and also bring in quality kids so we won't slide in 2 years time. Add that to the depth we already have, A+

[slangman]

At a glance, 2 first round picks is overs for Beams.
But if you look at 2 x pick 18 then I�d say it�s about fair especially with where our list is at.
We are approaching the premiership window. Either we make a serious play for it (think Burgoyne to hawks) or we continue to hover around it without ever seriously threatening.

A bold move by the club. Yes it can go pear shaped.....but it could also be a masterstroke. Only time will tell but there�s no denying that we are (on paper) better than this year.

If we can get our players on the ground, we will be the team to beat.

[neil]

Kind of like when the handbaggers got Ottens was expensive but won a premiership so was great value

[K]

What did they pay for Ottens?

[Jezza]

[watt price tully]

In isolation poor. In cotnext of what Stui has pointed out pretty good. Would have preferred trade options that gave us sufficent points for both Quaynor and Kelly.

So gains are:

Roughhead
Beams
*Quaynor
*Kelly
(+ add the two Irish Lads)

Losses:

Two x first round picks
Fasolo

Not bad.

[slangman]

The Hawks gave up pick 9 and a very good small forward (Mark Williams) for some 28yo guy named Burgoyne....didn�t turn out too bad them😉

[K]

Who was that pick 9 used on?

[K]

[PyreneesPie]

[E]

there is confusion as to pick 56 and why we included that in the Beams trade. Shouldnt we have included pick 57 as it doesnt come with points? Did we screw this up.

[think positive]

[K]