Votes: Pies VS Saint QF

[Usurper]

3. Maxwell.
2. Thomas.
1. Toovey.

[kambarker]

[ktszyu1]

3. Maxwell
2. Sidebottom
0.5. Cloke
0.5 Thomas

[rocketronnie]

3) Maxwell

2) Thomas

1) Sidebottom

[panga]

3. Maxwell

The nullabor

2. Shaw
1. Thomas

Toovey, Brown, Rocca, Cloke, O'Brien are the only others that played ok.

[Hm]

3 - not voting
2 - not voting
1 - not voting

Gutless performance all round, how can you say we are a team yet say some performed and others didn't? Either they performed or they didn't we lost a final and if we perform the same against the Crows it will be 3 losses in a row since losing "Brad" Scott.

[gregpie]

3 Cloke
2. Maxwell
1 Shaw

-10 O'Bree

[think positive]

1 maxwell

2. thomas

3. shaw - amazing

koodoos to rocca, steele,
and big surprise for me toovey

[Monco Matt]

3. Maxwell - Saints would have kicked 16 or 17 goals if not for his efforts.
2. Cloke - We wouldn't have had any inside 50's without his efforts.
1. Thomas - We would have kicked 3 or 4 goals if not for his efforts.

One of the worst games I have seen from Leon Davis, this effort was a 2000/2001/2002 rewind, back to his flashy old ways not wanting to get the hard ball. So disappointed in Leon more than anyone else.

Sidey & Heater gave it their all and put their bodies on the line all day. I am now convinced that O'Bree & Lockyer WILL NEVER perform for us under pressure in BIG games, they are too small and panic too easily......trade/delist.

Really not happy right now, feel betrayed today by a couple of blokes I thought had turned the corner. Not mentioning any names...AD & LD.

[Wokko]

3. Maxwell

2. H. Shaw

1. L. Brown

*edit - giving 2 & 1 votes after some more thought.

[Macedonian Marvel #35]

3. Skipper

2. Daisy

1. Shaw

Steele and swan just miss

[Macedonian Marvel #35]

3. Skipper

2. Daisy

1. Shaw

Steele and swan just miss

[nathan92]

-1 mcarthy
-2 didak
-3 medhurst.

yes they are negatives.

[Akos]

3. Maxwell - you can always rely on him to do his job and get the best out of himself. i wonder how he goes in the Copeland trophy this year

2. Cloke - played a really good team game - presented all day for our midfielders, and got the ball into the forward line, i reckon he set up at least three goals

1. Thomas - i thought we needed someone to stand up while the Saints were applying the pressure. Didak and Davis seemed to not want to get their hands dirty, i thought Daisy at least tried to. He's had better games, but i reckon if more players had his endeavor, we'd have had a better day.

[Tannin]

Haven't seen the game yet, but going on the radio call for now (I'll edit my post later if I change my mind) ....

3: Toovey. Just about the only midfielder who can hold his head up. Never gave up, got a lot of ball.

2: Cloke. Dominated in t he first half, took a lot of marks. Kicked horrible, as usual. Why, why, why does MM insist on playing him out of position. Could be an All-Australian if he was played where he belongs: centre-half back.

1: Thomas. Didn't get it a lot, but kicked true and displayed enormous courage.

Stiff to miss: Nick.

Missing in action: most of the others.