Pre-Match. Pies v. Dockers. All comments.
Moderator: bbmods
-
Piesnchess
- Posts: 26202
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2008 4:24 pm
- Has liked: 229 times
- Been liked: 94 times
Freo up and down like a friggin yo yo, but are 4 goals better team at home. Our interstate record is awesome, and if we had our best side in, Id be pretty confident. But injuries have hit us hard, and this maybe a bridge too far, this match, in Perth, because of that fact. Be a close match, as per usual , but this is going to be very hard to win. i expect a close loss, but with the Woods, you just never know, Fly may yet pull off a miracle victory.
Poverty exists not because we cannot feed the poor, but because we cannot satisfy the rich.
Chess and Vodka are born brothers. - Russian proverb.
Chess and Vodka are born brothers. - Russian proverb.
-
lazzadesilva
- Posts: 2266
- Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2003 8:01 pm
- Has liked: 2 times
- Been liked: 94 times
As per last week, it’s going to be a very close game. We bond well on these interstate trips and will be hard to beat even in their backyard. I think it will be a 55/45 game and we will sneak home by 8 - 12 points.
I term the current Collingwood attack based strategy “Unceasing Waves” like on a stormy and windy day with rough seas. A Perfect Storm 
-
think better
- Posts: 3113
- Joined: Mon May 16, 2005 4:42 pm
- Location: Adelaide
- Has liked: 2 times
- Been liked: 40 times
Freo are becoming a very good side - hot midfield that will be hard to beat/contain.
It seems like Allan is close to a call up not sure how the ins and outs will go.
Out - WHE and McInnes - anyone else? (maybe Oleg or Sidey being managed)
In - Mihocek and McCreery - (Maybe Allan)
It seems like Allan is close to a call up not sure how the ins and outs will go.
Out - WHE and McInnes - anyone else? (maybe Oleg or Sidey being managed)
In - Mihocek and McCreery - (Maybe Allan)
I think therefore I think - I think
-
rad
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2012 6:46 pm
Time for Krueger. Break glass in emergency and see what happens.
I have on too many occasions spruiked Freddy to my Collingwood mates but time and time again he has let me down.
He was brought in as a FF. He is 196cm, 98 kgs, aggressive. He has played 9 games in 5 seasons.
It’s time to step up and be counted. IMO a competitive Freddy that could survive the remainder of the season could be the difference of a flag or not. McStay isn’t the greatest FF but stood tall in the finals series to help us win the flag.
Wade and high performance team should focus to getting Freddy up for the amount of games they think he can cope with. In the background keep plugging away at McStay in case he is needed.
This to me is Kruegers final chance to really make his mark and extend his AFL career or otherwise cut him off the list as another failed Collingwood bargain basement buy to fill FF. God knows we’ve had a few in recent times.
I have on too many occasions spruiked Freddy to my Collingwood mates but time and time again he has let me down.
He was brought in as a FF. He is 196cm, 98 kgs, aggressive. He has played 9 games in 5 seasons.
It’s time to step up and be counted. IMO a competitive Freddy that could survive the remainder of the season could be the difference of a flag or not. McStay isn’t the greatest FF but stood tall in the finals series to help us win the flag.
Wade and high performance team should focus to getting Freddy up for the amount of games they think he can cope with. In the background keep plugging away at McStay in case he is needed.
This to me is Kruegers final chance to really make his mark and extend his AFL career or otherwise cut him off the list as another failed Collingwood bargain basement buy to fill FF. God knows we’ve had a few in recent times.
If Checkers remains unavailable and Freddie is no chance, then I suspect we will go in to this game with a fleet of small forwards, with JDG and Cox as our marking options.
There's no reason to rush back Mitchell for this game. Earlier on I suggested dropping Macrae, but that was clearly too harsh on the kid. He'll surely keep his spot.
Assuming that's the case, my preferred changes would be:
Out: WHE, McInnes
In: McCreery, Allan (sub)
There's no reason to rush back Mitchell for this game. Earlier on I suggested dropping Macrae, but that was clearly too harsh on the kid. He'll surely keep his spot.
Assuming that's the case, my preferred changes would be:
Out: WHE, McInnes
In: McCreery, Allan (sub)
My guess is that JDG will be rested again this week. He is too valuable a player to risk further groin damage. We will need him firing on all cylinders come September.
Knowing how tough Checkers is, and after reading the club's injury report, I expect he'll play. After Allan getting the coaches MVP award for his last VFL game, it's surely time to debut Allan. I've got massive hopes for this kid, though it may take him a season to adjust to senior footy. He is highly skilled, an elite athlete, fast and big sized midfielder. What's not to like about him.
Ins: Checkers, McCreery, Allan (sub)
Outs: McInnes, WHE, JDG
Knowing how tough Checkers is, and after reading the club's injury report, I expect he'll play. After Allan getting the coaches MVP award for his last VFL game, it's surely time to debut Allan. I've got massive hopes for this kid, though it may take him a season to adjust to senior footy. He is highly skilled, an elite athlete, fast and big sized midfielder. What's not to like about him.
Ins: Checkers, McCreery, Allan (sub)
Outs: McInnes, WHE, JDG
Think this will be a big test for us. They are finding some form and have a pretty even balance around the park. Emerging tall forwards, good ruck and midfield stocks and a pretty stingy backline. Add in some speed with the likes of Frederick and Switkowski and they could be a handful.
They lost to Carlton and Port in Adelaide when they arguably should have won both, beat the dogs at home, but also got rolled by the eagles (huh?) and Sydney (many will lose to the Swans this year). Coming to Marvel and rolling the Saints should count as a reasonable win.
They may have had their trough in form for now and will surely be setting themselves for this one in a coveted Friday night slot (their third and last for the season). We, on the other hand, are going ok - albeit as a bit of a patchwork team at present (and that will likely be the case Friday too). Will depend a bit on who gets up and gets picked. I am inclined to rest Jordy if in doubt (we have Dogs and Melbourne next) and ask Sullivan, Macrae and Richards to step up again.
They lost to Carlton and Port in Adelaide when they arguably should have won both, beat the dogs at home, but also got rolled by the eagles (huh?) and Sydney (many will lose to the Swans this year). Coming to Marvel and rolling the Saints should count as a reasonable win.
They may have had their trough in form for now and will surely be setting themselves for this one in a coveted Friday night slot (their third and last for the season). We, on the other hand, are going ok - albeit as a bit of a patchwork team at present (and that will likely be the case Friday too). Will depend a bit on who gets up and gets picked. I am inclined to rest Jordy if in doubt (we have Dogs and Melbourne next) and ask Sullivan, Macrae and Richards to step up again.
It's never as good/nor bad as it seems...
-
Take_a_Screamer
- Posts: 2065
- Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2018 8:51 pm
- Location: Melbourne S.E.Suburbs
- Has liked: 10 times
- Been liked: 39 times
- Contact:
-
warburton lad
- Posts: 2786
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2003 10:47 am
- Has liked: 1 time
- Been liked: 60 times
Frederick was concussed so he won't play for them.
Out: McInnes and WHE.
Ins: Mihocek/Krueger and McCreery
If Mihocek doesn't get up, Krueger must play.
As stated previously, at 196cms and almost 100kgs, Krueger is a very big unit.
I would play Krueger and De Goey out of the goal square and change Cameron and Cox off the bench.
Again, if we can scrounge 13-14 goals, our backline should be able to hold the Freo forwards to a losing total.
Under no circumstance should Mitchell, Mihocek or any others be rushed back in to the 23- it is a bloody long season and we can't have players getting reinsured again.
This is one we may well drop, but it won't be without a hell of a fight..
Floreat Pica.
Out: McInnes and WHE.
Ins: Mihocek/Krueger and McCreery
If Mihocek doesn't get up, Krueger must play.
As stated previously, at 196cms and almost 100kgs, Krueger is a very big unit.
I would play Krueger and De Goey out of the goal square and change Cameron and Cox off the bench.
Again, if we can scrounge 13-14 goals, our backline should be able to hold the Freo forwards to a losing total.
Under no circumstance should Mitchell, Mihocek or any others be rushed back in to the 23- it is a bloody long season and we can't have players getting reinsured again.
This is one we may well drop, but it won't be without a hell of a fight..
Floreat Pica.
Firm in the belief that number 17 flag is only months away...