Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

I'd drop him. He costs us weekly. Ruins our momentum with shit kicks or overly ambitious kicks. I've had enough of him. At least Tom Mitchell plays within his limitations. Adams thinks he's Buckley.

One of the worst. You are correct.

Perhaps I'm just expressing my own concern about it.

Might be easier to name the good kicks, faster anyway

We've been here before. We know he can't kick. They even "identfied" it in the review because they couldn't see what thousands of supporters can see.

The question is..what are they doing it about it? Be transparent Collingwood. What are you actually doing about it?
I feel sorry for Tay because his coaches haven't been able to improve his one deficiency in his game. And to think Buckley was his coach when he was 16. Maybe that says a lot.

think positive wrote:Might be easier to name the good kicks, faster anyway

Interesting point.
Who are the good kicks in our side.
Sidey is good albeit over a shorter distance.WHE yeah ok!
Pendles ...going backwards....so who are the really good kicks in our side????

masoncox wrote:

think positive wrote:Might be easier to name the good kicks, faster anyway

Interesting point.
Who are the good kicks in our side.
Sidey is good albeit over a shorter distance.WHE yeah ok!
Pendles ...going backwards....so who are the really good kicks in our side????

Stephenson, Howe, Dunn, Maynard, Thomas, Sidey, Phillips, WHE, Varcoe, Moore, Scharenberg, Wells are all excellent kicks.

Unfortunately, Treloar, Adams and Pendles are not good kicks.

E wrote:

masoncox wrote:

think positive wrote:Might be easier to name the good kicks, faster anyway

Interesting point.
Who are the good kicks in our side.
Sidey is good albeit over a shorter distance.WHE yeah ok!
Pendles ...going backwards....so who are the really good kicks in our side????

Stephenson, Howe, Dunn, Maynard, Thomas, Sidey, Phillips, WHE, Varcoe, Moore, Scharenberg, Wells are all excellent kicks.

Unfortunately, Treloar, Adams and Pendles are not good kicks.

Don't throw Pendlebury under the bus. He been a magician by hand AND foot for years. Rarely misses a target. For some reason his goal kicking has turned to shit the past few seasons.

E wrote:...
Stephenson, Howe, Dunn, Maynard, Thomas, Sidey, Phillips, WHE, Varcoe, Moore, Scharenberg, Wells are all excellent kicks.

Unfortunately, Treloar, Adams and Pendles are not good kicks.

That's a provocative claim. A very lax definition of "excellent" seems to be used. Some of those on the list are very good in a limited sense (very good at a certain type of kick, but not at all types of kicks). Some blow hot and cold with their kicking. I'd like it to be true of Flip, even in a limited sense, but is it? Varcoe is a turnover merchant.

Adams and Treloar - both shocking kicks.

Adams at least hard at it.

Treloar and Pendles are too soft.

Pendles has given up on trying.

The Boy Who Cried Wolf wrote:

Haff wrote:Oscar Pistorius was a better kick...

he's certainly more on target

He's here all week folks! Try the veal!

Is Josh Thomas the worst kick at goal in the AFL?

^ No. Even within the 'family', Daisy is far worse.