Page 2 of 26
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:42 pm
by commonwombat
he was drunk at the time
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:46 pm
by nathan
maggies2003 wrote:#1 Leon Davis - Tradeable/Delisted
#2 Shane Woewoden - Safe
#3 Mark Richardson - Retired
#4 Alan Didak - Safe
#5 Nathan Buckley - Safe
#6 Brodie Holland - Safe
#7 Jarrod Molly - Retired/Delisted
#8 James Clement - Safe
#9 Glen Freeborne - Retired
#10 Rupert Betheras - Tradeable
#11 Shane Obree - Tradeable
#12 Steve McKee - Delisted
#13 Richard Cole - Safe
#14 Shane Wakelin - Safe
#17 Scott Burns - Safe
#18 Paul Licuria - Safe
#19 Andrew Williams - Delisted/Tradeable
#20 Chris Tarrant - Safe
#22 Rhyce Shaw - Tradeable
#23 Anthony Rocca - Safe
#24 Tarkyn Lockyer - Safe
#25 Josh Fraser - Safe
#26 Ben Johnson - Safe
#27 Mark McGough - Tradeable
#28 Ben Kinnear - Safe
#29 Heath Scotland - Tradeable
#34 Jason Cloke - Safe
#35 Simon Prestigiacomo - Safe
#37 Ryan Lonie - Safe
#38 Tristen Walker - Safe
#39 Matthew Lokan - Safe
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:53 pm
by nathan
Lonie is tradeable or at least next year he needs to step up and play a more important role for us. Sure he looks good kicking the long goals but sadly they are very infrequent. Kinnear is either delisted or tradeable as this guy will never win a flag for us. Shaw deserves another chance along with Cole they are both only very young and have got good leg speed. I think nerves played a big part in both of their performances today. Long term they will be exciting players.
hewhe
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:55 pm
by sherrife
KINNEAR SAFE??? wtf hes done nothing all his life! wat a tooooll
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:57 pm
by Morrigu
KINNEAR safe - has to go!!!!!
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:57 pm
by blackmissionary
I wouldn't trade Betheras or McGough, because while they aren't the most skillful players in the side, I personally have never been able to fault them for courage and effort. If, however, Shane O'Bree is still here by the end of the year, well then I think we have some problems. Can someone tell me what he does?
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:58 pm
by blackmissionary
I wouldn't trade Betheras or McGough, because while they aren't the most skillful players in the side, I personally have never been able to fault them for courage and effort. If, however, Shane O'Bree is still here by the end of the year, well then I think we have some problems. Can someone tell me what he does?
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 7:59 pm
by I_love_Clokey
Richie cole and Rhyce Shaw just had bad days becuase they were nervous and who can balme them!! and if everyone who is bagging them was in their position they would have been shit scared too so leave them alone!!!!
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:06 pm
by johnny@
Trade/Borderline/Delist
#2 Shane Woewoden - Trade
#7 Jarrod Molly - Delist
#10 Rupert Betheras - Borderline
#11 Shane Obree - Trade
#19 Andrew Williams - Borderline
#22 Rhyce Shaw - Borderline
#27 Mark McGough - Borderline
#28 Ben Kinnear - Borderline
Re: hewhe
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:07 pm
by labrooy
sherrife wrote:KINNEAR SAFE??? wtf hes done nothing all his life! wat a tooooll
Maybe you can tell us what you have done all your life? He has a go with the limited ability he has. Do you?
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:13 pm
by nathan
Nick Stevens must be a priority for us. If we have to trade O'Bree, Kinnear, McGough, Williams & Betheras to get him I would do it. This guy is A GRADE QUALITY. Let's do whatever it takes to get him. He wants to play for us so we must make him our no 1 recruiting priority. I agree that Woewoden is tradeable but I really do not think that anyone would want him. He is simply too slow for today's modern football.
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:16 pm
by labrooy
The only way to get Stevens would be to trade quality players. Heath Scotland would be the one. Also a draft pick.
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:17 pm
by Morrigu
I think Goughy is in trouble - agreed to a new contract months ago and Collingwood has not come back to him!!
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:18 pm
by I_love_Clokey
Why do you people want to have Nick Stevens at Collingwood???
Posted: Sat Sep 27, 2003 8:23 pm
by Morrigu
Has a shi*tful time at PA this year - played injured played out of position detests chokeo wants to play for us and could under Mick's guidance be a bloody good player in the black and white - and is only 23 years of age