Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

WhyPhilWhy? wrote:What about:
-dids to the crows (I know, I know)
- stenglein to the weagles
- our first round draft pick to the weagles
- leon to the weagles (again, I know)
- judd to us?

Nearly worth it.

Is Judd really worth 3 of our players (2 players and draft pick)?

sq3 wrote:Why Massie ?

1. Faster than OB,
2. Better disposal on both sides of the body,
3. Younger,
4. Tougher.

He gets the ball a lot and will be better in our midfield than OB - and I forgot to mention - can kick goals.

But he is just as inconsistant and still can't nail down a spot in the Crows side. If we are looking at the Crwos, go for Bode and Ladhams.

WPW, that is a great idea but highly unlikely. See if you can pass it on to the club.

Johnson#26 wrote:

sq3 wrote:Why Massie ?

1. Faster than OB,
2. Better disposal on both sides of the body,
3. Younger,
4. Tougher.

He gets the ball a lot and will be better in our midfield than OB - and I forgot to mention - can kick goals.

But he is just as inconsistant and still can't nail down a spot in the Crows side. If we are looking at the Crwos, go for Bode and Ladhams.

WPW, that is a great idea but highly unlikely. See if you can pass it on to the club.

Don't forget that he was delisted from Carlton after struggling to get a game for them in 2001.

Yes Daks, he has been in the system since 1998, and that is way too long for us to tak him. We have more then enough players of a similar ilk such as Johnson, Cole and Rhyce Shaw. He has not really ever consolidated his position in the side, and will be some trade bait this season. He isn't required.

If we are going to eye off some Crows players, we need to look at Matthew Bode and Chris Ladhams.

Then again Massie was a Collingwood supporter as a kid and a lot of people on here seem to think that is important.

Massie would only cost a low draft pick or a Lokan plus a Crow draft pick - cheap.

Young kid that will be bakc in Victoria and play for the team he followed.

Very, very similar to Travis Johnstone - but will be way cheaper.

Would be far better on our list than BK.

After watching Johnstone today i would definitely try and lure him.

Cam wrote:After watching Johnstone today i would definitely try and lure him.

Same here. He is a star, although the Dees will fight to get a good deal.