Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

CarringbushCigar wrote:

Piesnchess wrote:

CarringbushCigar wrote: Go watch the 2011 Prelim.
I find your vindictiveness absolutely absurd.

His last three seasons have been shite, or do you enjoy seeing him miss soda goals constantly and letting the team down. That, is absurd. The Dishlickers Welfare are welcome too him, he cannot hit the broad side of a barn door now.

No mate I've never enjoyed his erratic goal kicking, but accepted he is a fragile soul after about his 10th game.

His last three seasons have been twice as good as Jesse White who it seems will be carrying the hopes of emerging into our next premiership CHF.

I much rather keep proven premiership players like Cloke and Brown and many others and try a new coach. They have been as serviceable and black and white blooded as it comes, and they have had enough.
Supporters who react by saying - we don't need em, they are finished, get what you can for them or delist them make me sick.

Any dissent with the great Bucks and you are out of there.
The last 5 years are littered with broken relationships.

Cloke's talent is undeniable, his on-field effort has rarely been questioned and never in big games. He played some very good games for us in 2016, better than anyone else in the comp who was dropped 3 times.
Is it any surprise he got frustrated?

Im sick to death of players who don't want to be at Collingwood, and to me it is clear there is one common factor.
Every single piece of innuendo and circumstantial evidence points to the fact that the Collingwood FC is not as happy a place as it once was.

If you want a bet who will next win a final, I'll back Cloke over Buckley.

Who wants some action?

HAL wrote:Almost everyone.

CarringbushCigar wrote:

Piesnchess wrote:

CarringbushCigar wrote: Go watch the 2011 Prelim.
I find your vindictiveness absolutely absurd.

His last three seasons have been shite, or do you enjoy seeing him miss soda goals constantly and letting the team down. That, is absurd. The Dishlickers Welfare are welcome too him, he cannot hit the broad side of a barn door now.

No mate I've never enjoyed his erratic goal kicking, but accepted he is a fragile soul after about his 10th game.

His last three seasons have been twice as good as Jesse White who it seems will be carrying the hopes of emerging into our next premiership CHF.

I much rather keep proven premiership players like Cloke and Brown and many others and try a new coach. They have been as serviceable and black and white blooded as it comes, and they have had enough.
Supporters who react by saying - we don't need em, they are finished, get what you can for them or delist them make me sick.

Any dissent with the great Bucks and you are out of there.
The last 5 years are littered with broken relationships.

Cloke's talent is undeniable, his on-field effort has rarely been questioned and never in big games. He played some very good games for us in 2016, better than anyone else in the comp who was dropped 3 times.
Is it any surprise he got frustrated?

Im sick to death of players who don't want to be at Collingwood, and to me it is clear there is one common factor.
Every single piece of innuendo and circumstantial evidence points to the fact that the Collingwood FC is not as happy a place as it once was.

If you want a bet who will next win a final, I'll back Cloke over Buckley.

Who wants some action?

mooretreloar wrote:

CarringbushCigar wrote:

Piesnchess wrote: His last three seasons have been shite, or do you enjoy seeing him miss soda goals constantly and letting the team down. That, is absurd. The Dishlickers Welfare are welcome too him, he cannot hit the broad side of a barn door now.

No mate I've never enjoyed his erratic goal kicking, but accepted he is a fragile soul after about his 10th game.

His last three seasons have been twice as good as Jesse White who it seems will be carrying the hopes of emerging into our next premiership CHF.

I much rather keep proven premiership players like Cloke and Brown and many others and try a new coach. They have been as serviceable and black and white blooded as it comes, and they have had enough.
Supporters who react by saying - we don't need em, they are finished, get what you can for them or delist them make me sick.

Any dissent with the great Bucks and you are out of there.
The last 5 years are littered with broken relationships.

Cloke's talent is undeniable, his on-field effort has rarely been questioned and never in big games. He played some very good games for us in 2016, better than anyone else in the comp who was dropped 3 times.
Is it any surprise he got frustrated?

Im sick to death of players who don't want to be at Collingwood, and to me it is clear there is one common factor.
Every single piece of innuendo and circumstantial evidence points to the fact that the Collingwood FC is not as happy a place as it once was.

If you want a bet who will next win a final, I'll back Cloke over Buckley.

Who wants some action?

I will give credit where it is due. That is, a very well put together post. I disagree with your conclusions, but you set out your arguments and provided support, rather than the cop out of just saying is Buckley's fault.

Does finals include VFL finals, as that is where Cloke will be playing wherever he goes?

STOKA35 wrote:

mooretreloar wrote:

CarringbushCigar wrote: No mate I've never enjoyed his erratic goal kicking, but accepted he is a fragile soul after about his 10th game.

His last three seasons have been twice as good as Jesse White who it seems will be carrying the hopes of emerging into our next premiership CHF.

I much rather keep proven premiership players like Cloke and Brown and many others and try a new coach. They have been as serviceable and black and white blooded as it comes, and they have had enough.
Supporters who react by saying - we don't need em, they are finished, get what you can for them or delist them make me sick.

Any dissent with the great Bucks and you are out of there.
The last 5 years are littered with broken relationships.

Cloke's talent is undeniable, his on-field effort has rarely been questioned and never in big games. He played some very good games for us in 2016, better than anyone else in the comp who was dropped 3 times.
Is it any surprise he got frustrated?

Im sick to death of players who don't want to be at Collingwood, and to me it is clear there is one common factor.
Every single piece of innuendo and circumstantial evidence points to the fact that the Collingwood FC is not as happy a place as it once was.

If you want a bet who will next win a final, I'll back Cloke over Buckley.

Who wants some action?

I will give credit where it is due. That is, a very well put together post. I disagree with your conclusions, but you set out your arguments and provided support, rather than the cop out of just saying is Buckley's fault.

Does finals include VFL finals, as that is where Cloke will be playing wherever he goes?

One day the truth will come out with Buckley and the playing group

Pies4shaw wrote:

STOKA35 wrote:

mooretreloar wrote: I will give credit where it is due. That is, a very well put together post. I disagree with your conclusions, but you set out your arguments and provided support, rather than the cop out of just saying is Buckley's fault.

Does finals include VFL finals, as that is where Cloke will be playing wherever he goes?

One day the truth will come out with Buckley and the playing group

It'll probably take a little longer than usual for the truth to come out - normally, the reporters just wander down to the Club and chat to a few of the players but here they'll have to wander down to at least 7 other clubs on my present count (including one in each of NSW, Qld, SA and WA).

Cam wrote:Remembering Daisy's first game against us and how it affected him, I shudder to think about what that kind of atmosphere would do to Trav.

eddiesmith wrote:

Cam wrote:Remembering Daisy's first game against us and how it affected him, I shudder to think about what that kind of atmosphere would do to Trav.

lol, comparing the mental midget Daisy to Travis, Dales problems were he never grew up so no surprise he struggled

I will predict he will kick 6.1 in the first game against us, 8.2 if its at the MCG

eddiesmith wrote:

Cam wrote:Remembering Daisy's first game against us and how it affected him, I shudder to think about what that kind of atmosphere would do to Trav.

lol, comparing the mental midget Daisy to Travis, Dales problems were he never grew up so no surprise he struggled

I will predict he will kick 6.1 in the first game against us, 8.2 if its at the MCG

Cam wrote:

eddiesmith wrote:

Cam wrote:Remembering Daisy's first game against us and how it affected him, I shudder to think about what that kind of atmosphere would do to Trav.

lol, comparing the mental midget Daisy to Travis, Dales problems were he never grew up so no surprise he struggled

I will predict he will kick 6.1 in the first game against us, 8.2 if its at the MCG

Thank you David. But back to reality.

60k people jeering if he misses won't be great. And we all know what happens if he misses early. He said it himself. Hell, we've SEEN it for 10 yrs, much to our fear, trepidation as he runs in and chagrin. And you can't blame Buckley for that.

eddiesmith wrote:

Cam wrote:Remembering Daisy's first game against us and how it affected him, I shudder to think about what that kind of atmosphere would do to Trav.

lol, comparing the mental midget Daisy to Travis, Dales problems were he never grew up so no surprise he struggled

I will predict he will kick 6.1 in the first game against us, 8.2 if its at the MCG

Pies4shaw wrote:

STOKA35 wrote:

mooretreloar wrote: I will give credit where it is due. That is, a very well put together post. I disagree with your conclusions, but you set out your arguments and provided support, rather than the cop out of just saying is Buckley's fault.

Does finals include VFL finals, as that is where Cloke will be playing wherever he goes?

One day the truth will come out with Buckley and the playing group

It'll probably take a little longer than usual for the truth to come out - normally, the reporters just wander down to the Club and chat to a few of the players but here they'll have to wander down to at least 7 other clubs on my present count (including one in each of NSW, Qld, SA and WA).