Adam Treloar

[John Wren]

Just a word of warning people: this story was started by Damian Barrett, who raised it with Plough on trade radio so of course there could be Jack schitt in it

So, it was started by an Ambulance Chaser, and a dud coach. That pretty much puts this one to bed.

i like wallace and what he says holds greater credence than the ambulance chaser.

[OEP]

The possibility of GWS being interested in Dayne is great, means I can make another ridiculous trade proposal that results in the Pies getting picks and Cameron McCarthy

Sooooooooooooooo,

We send Dayne and pick 30 to GWS for Cameron McCarthy, picks 4 and 21.
We send Harry, picks 4 and 48 to Melbourne for picks 2 and 23.
We then use pick 23 to obtain Levi from the Kangas.

We lose Dayne, Harry, picks 30 and 48.
We gain Levi, McCarthy, picks 2 and 21.

We use pick 2 on either Petracca or Brayshaw, pick 8 on Darcy, and pick 21 on Clem Smith.

Happy days .

[inxs88]

Hey Barrett aint no muppet! He is a PURPLE muppet

[Jameoz23]

I'd do this:

Pick 5 + Patfull to GWS

Treloar to COLL + Pick 25 to Coll (from GWS)

Beams to BRIS

This is the most fair trade for all 3 clubs. The lions and the Giants get the players and picks they want, and we get a player that will be a great midfielder going forward. Considering we have put years of time into Beams, Treloar will be at that standard in a year or two, if we want to get something worth while out of this trade season we need to make a trade like this.

[Domesticated_Ape]

What about Dylan Shiel? I read somewhere that he might want to come back to Victoria. He and Treloar are the two best GWS midfielders apart from Josh Kelly IMO. I'd be more than happy to ontrade pick 5 for any of these guys, though the Giants would be silly to do it.

[Stupied]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

[Captain_MyCaptain]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

Nope.

Beams > Griffin.
Treloar + 5 to Pies.
4 plus 21 to Dogs.

[Breadcrawl]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

Dogs third rounder to Pies and you gotta deal.

But Treloar is going nowhere. End of story. He is very much a required player

[swoop42]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

Great for the dogs but not as much for us or especially GWS

Beams to Brisbane.

Griffin + Patful +25 (Lions) to GWS. (they keep 21 for Patful and 7 for Jaksch)

Treloar + 6 (dogs) to Pies.

Pick 4 (GWS) + Pick 5 (Lions) + 30 (Pies) to Dogs.

[MJ23]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

Nope.

Beams > Griffin.
Treloar + 5 to Pies.
4 plus 21 to Dogs.

Nope Treloar = Beams right now.
Treloar is younger and in our side would be our second best player.

[MJ23]

Beams to Brisbane
Griffin to GWS
Treloar + 21 (Lions)to Pies
Pick 4(GWS) + pick 5 (Lions) to Dogs

Sounds fair?

Dogs third rounder to Pies and you gotta deal.

But Treloar is going nowhere. End of story. He is very much a required player

Really depends on what GWS knows of his intent next year.
If they think they have a year of speculation and dragged out efforts to get him to stay , as it stands he is worth it.
IF though they get Griffith and Beams it would make the loss bearable this year and keep the members reasonably happy.

[CarringbushCigar]

unders for the dogs swoop

we don't need more than treloar for beams

[MJ23]

^ keep saying it.
I watch a lot of Treloar live.
He is worth a straight swap.

Look forward to revisiting these comments in a few years - will take one, two at most

[swoop42]

No way do the dogs get to keep pick 6 and receive 4 and 5 for Griffin.

Stuff that for a joke.

GWS have clearly stated that Treloar wont be traded so it's all moot anyway.

Looking at his stats he seems very similar to Beams though not as big a goal kicker at this stage.

Like Beams there is a bit of an unbalance when it comes to rebound 50's compared to inside 50's.

I dare say like Beams he works harder forward of the ball than behind it.

What price goals though?

[John Wren]

^ keep saying it.
I watch a lot of Treloar live.
He is worth a straight swap.

Look forward to revisiting these comments in a few years - will take one, two at most

in a few years treloar will be one of the comp's best. would so love to see him in black and white.