This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker on our website.
qldmagpie67 wrote:I know we all see the game differently but can't believe how little love for Treloar there is
35 touches at 91.4% 13 inside 50's half his touches were contested and some people think he's only worth a single vote in GB medal was clearly most valuable player on the ground yesterday
The club agrees with you qldmagpie and so do I. A brilliant game by him.
Crisp was very good again as well has really developed into one of most important players
Shaz 22 @95% shows why he's so highly rated by the coaches putting it in his hands means it's going to a team mate next not a turnover
Absolutely agree with these comments too and thanks for highlighting the strengths of Crisp and Shaz. Backs often don't get much of the credit when the team wins and I thought they gelled really well yesterday, getting the ball cleanly out of defence on nearly every occasion. Crisp is becoming a bit of an "every where" man, which makes it really hard for opposition to curb his influence.
Very good comments on Treloar.
His game as pure midfielder was one of best by anyone this season.
Heaps of footy both inside and out and his metres gained was off the charts.
He had 300 metres gained at qtr time alone and that’s usually an ok result if you do it over the entire game.
Anyone who talks about Treloar not trying or not having a go or chucking it in or whatever, simply has no clue. You don’t lead the competition for touches without busting your gut every week.
Can be sloppy on occasions but he also looks like he’s improving on that at the business end.
We are quick to bag our medical team but Treloar at least, seems to have been a very well managed rehab from those double hammys.
Gary Player “ the harder I practice, the luckier I get “
Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two and 4 by the other. The other coach must have awarded 5 to Sidey or Grundy. Depending upon which of those two got the other coach's 5, either Sidey was rated second best and third best or Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
Treloar has votes from everyone who has posted so far in the GB Medal. The more startling thing is that 6 out of 13 couldn't find it in their heart to give Sidebottom a vote for his 27 disposal, 2 goal, 11 score involvement game.
Last edited by Pies4shaw on Mon Aug 05, 2019 6:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Pies4shaw wrote:Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two. The other coach awarded 5 to Sidey. Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
To be fair, the other coach did give Treloar four votes
Sidey presumably pulled 5 + 2.
Personally, I’m staggered Treloar didn’t pull the perfect ten but coaches certainly see the game in a different dimension to supporters.
Treloar single handedly took the game away from them in the first half.
No biggie. Sidey certainly deserved a few votes for his performance also.
Pies4shaw wrote:Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two. The other coach awarded 5 to Sidey. Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
To be fair, the other coach did give Treloar four votes Sidey presumably pulled 5 + 2.
Personally, I’m staggered Treloar didn’t pull the perfect ten but coaches certainly see the game in a different dimension to supporters.
Treloar single handedly took the game away from them in the first half.
No biggie. Sidey certainly deserved a few votes for his performance also.
Or 4 and 3, if it matters. It is mathematically possible that Grundy got 5 and 1, Crisp 1 and 3 and Pendlebury and WHE a 2 each.
Well, Thor received 17 votes last year (10th) and he's having a better season this year. He probably won't win but he should be top 3, especially given that the umpires will now be looking for him as a votegetter and that Sidey (who, of course, finished second in the Brownlow last year) will take fewer votes from him this year. Pendles and Treloar, though, might take some votes from him.
Pies4shaw wrote:Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two and 4 by the other. The other coach must have awarded 5 to Sidey or Grundy. Depending upon which of those two got the other coach's 5, either Sidey was rated second best and third best or Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
Treloar has votes from everyone who has posted so far in the GB Medal. The more startling thing is that 6 out of 13 couldn't find it in their heart to give Sidebottom a vote for his 27 disposal, 2 goal, 11 score involvement game.
I had 5 of the 6 players who got votes including Sidey (not in same order as coaches) in my GB medal voting
Do I get a award as well
Pies4shaw wrote:Well, Thor received 17 votes last year (10th) and he's having a better season this year. He probably won't win but he should be top 3, especially given that the umpires will now be looking for him as a votegetter and that Sidey (who, of course, finished second in the Brownlow last year) will take fewer votes from him this year. Pendles and Treloar, though, might take some votes from him.
Treloar will be our leading vote getter for the simple fact it's a midfielders award generally
I expect Grundy to poll well but our poor form after the bye will stop him finishing top 3 IMO
I have Treloar on 19-23 votes thus far (in my private count) and Grundy on 14-17 votes
Pies4shaw wrote:Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two and 4 by the other. The other coach must have awarded 5 to Sidey or Grundy. Depending upon which of those two got the other coach's 5, either Sidey was rated second best and third best or Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
Treloar has votes from everyone who has posted so far in the GB Medal. The more startling thing is that 6 out of 13 couldn't find it in their heart to give Sidebottom a vote for his 27 disposal, 2 goal, 11 score involvement game.
I had 5 of the 6 players who got votes including Sidey (not in same order as coaches) in my GB medal voting
Do I get a award as well
Pies4shaw wrote:Interestingly, from the coaches' votes, Treloar was rated 5 by only one of the two and 4 by the other. The other coach must have awarded 5 to Sidey or Grundy. Depending upon which of those two got the other coach's 5, either Sidey was rated second best and third best or Grundy was rated third best by both coaches.
Treloar has votes from everyone who has posted so far in the GB Medal. The more startling thing is that 6 out of 13 couldn't find it in their heart to give Sidebottom a vote for his 27 disposal, 2 goal, 11 score involvement game.
I had 5 of the 6 players who got votes including Sidey (not in same order as coaches) in my GB medal voting
Do I get a award as well
Pies2016 wrote:
That win actually means 4 points and a percentage boost but don’t let that cloud your thinking.
Generally you set out to win today before you start worrying about next weeks challenge.
