Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

Cameron doesn’t hold a candle to Grundy. Ned Guy can get $@&^#. Absolutely $@&^# us in the arse.

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

We have said that every time we lose and the exact opposite when we win. It’s done and dusted now so we find out over the next few weeks where things lie.

Johnno75 wrote:

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

We have said that every time we lose and the exact opposite when we win. It’s done and dusted now so we find out over the next few weeks where things lie.

I agree, the point is he was no chance of playing....would we have won? Maybe...maybe not...it is unanswerable


Like saying..what if Moore had played in the 2018 granny? Sadly he didn't....would we have defiantly have won if he had??? God knows..what if the ball had bounced a different direction for Milne in 2010???

eddiesmith wrote:

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

We lost our last PF with him getting 70 hitouts to GWS at the MCG…

If Grundy wasn’t injured we don’t even make the Prelim, the club will be so much stronger without him.

Lucky we’re keeping the (alleged) match-winner - where would we have been without his 12 disposals today?

The big question for Grundy is:

Do you want success or the money??

If it’s success, we need you to take a pay cut to allow us to bring in more quality players.

If it’s about the money….see ya later!!!

Pies4shaw wrote:

eddiesmith wrote:

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

We lost our last PF with him getting 70 hitouts to GWS at the MCG…

If Grundy wasn’t injured we don’t even make the Prelim, the club will be so much stronger without him.

Lucky we’re keeping the (alleged) match-winner - where would we have been without his 12 disposals today?

Well without JDG we aren’t even playing today or last week so I know who’d I’d rather keep.

But you’re not a true Collingwood fan, just a Grundy lover.

eddiesmith wrote:

Pies4shaw wrote:

eddiesmith wrote:

We lost our last PF with him getting 70 hitouts to GWS at the MCG…

If Grundy wasn’t injured we don’t even make the Prelim, the club will be so much stronger without him.

Lucky we’re keeping the (alleged) match-winner - where would we have been without his 12 disposals today?

Well without JDG we aren’t even playing today or last week so I know who’d I’d rather keep.

But you’re not a true Collingwood fan, just a Grundy lover.

How about you Piss Off you Troll

Dave The Man wrote: How about you Piss Off you Troll

Why are you back? Did you banned on BigFooty?

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

Yep, agree 101%...

Nicks is melting down.
But I agree. Grundy would have been the difference today.
The problem is he is on far too much. As I’ve said, Ned Guy farked us in the arse. We simply can’t keep him on the coin he’s on.

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

Only if he played well. There wasn’t much evidence of that in the last 2 years. Our wins since Freo in WA were without Grundy. Grundy barely takes a contested mark; Cox took 5 last week alone. Grundy at his best is a definite plus. Indeed the SCG would probably suit him. So it’s all speculation.

Best to ignore whatsinaname: she’s trying to get a rise out of you. Nice to hear from you DTM.

Dave The Man wrote: How about you Piss Off you Troll

Aww, poor Dave going to cry when you backed the wrong horse yet again? At least I know you are a true Collingwood fan so I'll let your anger slide.

watt price tully wrote:

Dave The Man wrote:IF Grundy played today we would of Won

Only if he played well. There wasn’t much evidence of that in the last 2 years. Our wins since Freo in WA were without Grundy. Grundy barely takes a contested mark; Cox took 5 last week alone. Grundy at his best is a definite plus. Indeed the SCG would probably suit him. So it’s all speculation.

Best to ignore whatsinaname: she’s trying to get a rise out of you. Nice to hear from you DTM.

It's 2022 mate. It's not a remotely funny or clever to call a male a female as some sort of insult. And don't come back with some lame excuse. You knew exactly what you were doing.

Grundy needs to stay. Cameron and Cox aren't our answer in the middle. Not enough c#nt in them. Cameron got schooled today by a spud that's been to 4 different clubs. How the f#ck was Hickey allowed to grab the footy at centre bounces???

Banksy wrote:Grundy needs to stay. Cameron and Cox aren't our answer in the middle. Not enough c#nt in them. Cameron got schooled today by a spud that's been to 4 different clubs. How the f#ck was Hickey allowed to grab the footy at centre bounces???

Cameron's been great, but has dropped away during the back end of this season.

Grundy has two more years of decent footy. Do we risk keeping him for those two and then carrying him for 3 more. I think it's the out years that are the worry.